# 2026-11-16 U.S. Koreas policy back to the future ![](2026-11-16.png) If you're an international relations academic working on any area of the Korean Peninsula, you've more than likely at one stage or another touched upon North Korea. It both looms over its southern neighbor like a late afternoon shadow, and also steals the spotlight like a sharpshooter at a sideshow. This is nowhere more true than in U.S. think-tank land--that wondrously fucked-up fairy-tale world of arms industry funding, washed up civil-servant wankery, and congress-targeted con-jobs. Over recent years, those attune to the outputs have more than likely started to sense a problem. U.S. Koreas policy being pushed in these circles is well out of date. It's near the end of 2026, and they're still pushing ideas from the 1990s. If you're a fan of [*Back to the Future*](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kWwcG1izaN0), what we have is a temporal event sequence--a break in the space-time continuum. Near every output shares three broad areas that would fit right into the 1990s. First, there's a consistent belief that any "solution" to the challenges of the region lies with Washington. Now it's understandable, everyone wants to think they're at the center of the world. But read enough of this fluff and you start to think the whole Korean Peninsula is sitting around waiting for the next Brzezinski-inspired Biden thought bubble or the next Trump brain fart. The questions are always what Washington wants, what Washington can offer, and what Washington should do next. The Biden and Trump administrations both demonstrated an incapacity to come to terms with temporal reality. Starting some time ago with a rhetorical Indo-Pacific flourish with near nothing to back it up, the U.S. ceased to be a state supporting regional security and became a state threatening regional security. Trump's 2017 fire 'n' fury fit, Biden's policy vacuity, and now Trump's Biden impersonation, point to any future efforts as inconsequential. Washington no longer presents the solution and appears incapable of providing it. Second, following on from the above, there's an uncannily awkward assumption that regardless of what's going on, updating the alliance is the starting point. As you get older and look back at the stuff you read in your younger days, you realize how little has changed. Thirty years of policy briefs, and everyone can name the single author who has consistently said the days of the alliance are behind us--if only Doug Bandow got as much attention as those wanting to update, modernize, make ironclad, deepen, broaden, future-proof, strengthen, diversify, make flexible, and solidify, the alliance! ![](2026-11-16b.png) The Iran conflict demonstrates that a U.S. alliance does not provide security. Hosting U.S. forces makes you a target. Iran struck U.S. bases across the Gulf, and the fighting drained American interceptor stocks. Seoul should ask how much protection Washington can really provide and how great is the risk of becoming involved as a front-line proxy. There's no point being a missile magnet in someone else's war. Third, there's an absolute dearth of creativity. Sticks and carrots. Ideas about sanctions that haven't worked for thirty years, and ideas about bilateral and multilateral talks that haven't worked for thirty years. A leadership summit? Wow! That's revolutionary! I mean, what could go wrong--it was so successful the first time around. The most imaginative thing in most reports is a new acronym. Together, the above leads to policy solutions that fit in a distinct time period--a time of U.S. ascendancy at the end of the Cold War--the unipolar moment. Thirty years back! Take most-near any U.S. think-tank publication on the Korean Peninsula over the last five years, and you're assured that the solutions proposed lie in what position the U.S. president takes; the strength and modernization of the alliance, and carrot and sticking of North Korea. It's 2026 Washington think-tank world!!! Wake up! The diplomatic solutions and even broad strategic approaches of the liberal-international order are today relevant only in the study of history. We are now entering a period when the U.S. is no longer central to the East Asian region; a period when everything learnt in the last thirty years of international relations textbooks means squat-diddly; and a period when diplomatic practice itself is transforming and adapting to a new era. ![](2026-11-16a.png) Now, if I were to stick my head on the railway tracks of the think-tank express, I'd suredly hear at least one critic carping on about how it's real easy to criticize, and much harder to create. Well, I've been near the railway tracks of the think-tank express, and had my body tied to the tracks. The fact is, nobody in Washington wants to hear solutions. They prefer affirmations. To suggest that the only solution to regional challenges is South Korea pursuing its own interests independently, and the U.S. acting as a responsible and distant supporter, does not go down well. Nobody in Washington wants to accept that East Asia has changed. Maybe they don't even realize it has changed? So, sooner or later, there'll be yet another think-tank express train pushing solutions from Washington, modernizing the alliance, and proposing solutions from three decades ago. They'll serve no useful purposeful, save letting me end this little piece with another express train analogy--she'll be [coming round the mountain](https://youtu.be/Ghd-xL5gAjc) when she comes, toot-toot! *** Help a thirsty time-travelling academic - [Buy Me a Coffee](https://buymeacoffee.com/junotane)